The tabloid fascination with the Brad Pitt-Jennifer Aniston-Angelina Jolie triangle shows no signs of abating, even years after the events that created it. The latest entry in this apparently inexhaustible narrative: reports claiming that Brad Pitt's parents have made their preference known, and that preference is for their son to return to his first marriage.

The story, sourced to unnamed individuals "close to the Pitt family," claims that Bill and Jane Pitt have never warmed to Jolie and have maintained an affection for Aniston that survived the divorce. This is presented as news, though it requires accepting that the private family preferences of two people in Springfield, Missouri constitute information the public has a legitimate interest in.

What the story actually illuminates, if anything, is the peculiar cultural status of the Pitt-Aniston relationship in the American celebrity imagination. The marriage lasted five years and ended over a decade ago, yet it continues to function as a kind of reference point — an idea about what was disrupted and might theoretically be restored. Aniston has built an entire secondary media persona around the dissolution, becoming a figure whose romantic life is treated as public property in ways that say more about cultural anxiety around female aging and romantic loss than they do about her actual circumstances.

Pitt and Jolie have six children together and by all public accounts a functioning partnership. Aniston has moved on. The parents, if they have preferences, have no particular power to act on them.

The story is not about Brad Pitt's parents. It is about the public's ongoing unwillingness to let the narrative end.