Pakistan minister speaks at Delhi SCO forum as India holds Indus treaty line

Musadik Malik is the first Pakistani minister to visit India since May 2023. New Delhi calls the visit multilateral protocol and says its Indus Waters Treaty stand has not moved. The opposition says the invitation contradicts the government's own line.

By M. Subramaniam4 min read
Pakistan minister speaks at Delhi SCO forum as India holds Indus treaty line

Featured image: A gateway of Purana Qila in New Delhi, the fort where India is hosting the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum from November 20 to 22, photographed on August 12, 2016. Photo by Moheen Reeyad, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Musadik Malik switched to Urdu at Purana Qila in New Delhi on Saturday. Speaking English felt strange a few miles from Mirza Ghalib's grave, he told the forum, ThePrint reported. "So I decided to speak to you in Urdu, the language of my heart," Malik said.

Malik is Pakistan's Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination. His trip is the first by a Pakistani federal minister to India since May 2023, when Bilawal Bhutto Zardari came to Goa for an SCO foreign ministers' meeting, The Indian Express reported. It is also the first since the 2025 fighting.

That fighting followed the Pahalgam attack of April 22, 2025, which killed 26 people. India put the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance after the attack, Deccan Herald reported. New Delhi has said normal ties depend on Pakistan acting against cross-border terrorism, The New Indian Express reported. No Pakistani minister had been invited to an Indian event since the May 2025 hostilities, Deccan Herald reported.

"This is a multilateral event within the SCO framework," the Ministry of External Affairs said on X on Friday, Deccan Herald reported. All 10 members got invitations, ANI reported. Observers and dialogue partners of a bloc that includes China and Russia were invited too.

New Delhi's invitation went to Pakistan's culture minister, Aurangzeb Khan Khichi, The Indian Express reported. Islamabad named Malik on November 14. In June, Malik threatened to "cut off those hands" that try to control the Indus waters. He has since said Pakistan is taking the dispute to the United Nations and arbitration forums, the paper reported.

Randhir Jaiswal, the ministry's spokesperson, faced that history at a briefing on Friday. He was asked about Malik's presence and his treaty remarks. "There is absolutely no change," Jaiswal said, Deccan Herald reported.

Nalin Kohli of the Bharatiya Janata Party made the governing party's argument at the forum the same day. "There can be no dialogue as long as terrorism is directed against us," Kohli said, according to Outlook. He said Pakistan had received no special invitation. He told the Congress to look at the foreign policy of Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi.

The opposition sees a contradiction. Supriya Shrinate, a Congress spokesperson, wrote on X that the government was "busy feeding them biryani and kheer," Outlook reported. Her post cited Malik's threats against India.

Deputy Chief Minister Surinder Choudhary of Jammu and Kashmir said the invitation vindicated the National Conference, The Hindu reported. His party's leaders, Farooq and Omar Abdullah, have urged dialogue with Pakistan. He said "the stance of my leaders was right then and is right now." Muntazir Mehdi, a People's Democratic Party legislator, called the visit "a welcome development."

Prime Minister Narendra Modi opened the forum on Friday evening. "Our shared civilizational experiences will play an important role in uniting the world," Modi said, according to the Prime Minister's Office. He proposed jointly digitizing ancient texts. The office's account of the speech does not mention Pakistan.

Malik has framed the trip as multilateral. "Everything here is happening in a multilateral context," he said on Friday, PTI reported. On cross-border terrorism, he said thousands had been killed in Pakistan in 18 to 24 months, ThePrint reported. "We have to bring transparency, we have to bring evidence from both sides," he said.

Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat chaired the Saturday session where Malik spoke, PTI reported. Pakistan's state news agency APP said Malik met Shekhawat and Culture Secretary Vivek Aggarwal on the sidelines, Dawn reported. It was not clear on Saturday whether New Delhi counted that as bilateral contact. India cleared a Taj Mahal visit and refused the Nizamuddin Dargah for security reasons, ThePrint reported.

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh announced India's plan to host the forum on October 20, at an SCO heads of government meeting in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, Hindustan Times reported. Pakistan chairs the SCO for 2026-27, ANI reported. Its Foreign Ministry said Islamabad will host ministerial meetings before the next summit.

The forum closes on Sunday, November 22. India's position on the Indus Waters Treaty has not changed, the ministry said on Friday. None of the officials quoted this week has named a date for talks with Islamabad.

PakistanMusadik MalikSCOShanghai Cooperation OrganisationPurana QilaIndus Waters TreatyMinistry of External AffairsRandhir JaiswalNarendra ModiOperation SindoorIndia-Pakistan relations

Share this story

Comments

Loading comments…

The Thoughtful India newsletter

The week’s best, in your inbox.

Related Stories

More Stories