Critics split on Ranbir Kapoor's Ram as Yash's Ravana steals Ramayana: Part 1

Critics in India, the Gulf, Britain and the US praise the spectacle and Yash's Ravana but divide over Ranbir Kapoor's Ram and the film's spiritual depth.

By Thoughtful India Staff7 min read
Critics split on Ranbir Kapoor's Ram as Yash's Ravana steals Ramayana: Part 1

Reviews, box-office counts and audience reaction to Nitesh Tiwari's two-part epic, which opened worldwide on November 5.

Top photo: "Jatayu Vadha," Raja Ravi Varma's 1906 oil painting of Ravana killing the vulture Jatayu as he tries to save Sita, in the Sri Jayachama Rajendra Art Gallery, Mysore. It is an artwork of the epic and has no connection with the film. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana: Part 1 runs 195 minutes, and the critics who sat through it kept returning to one figure on the screen. That was Yash's Ravana. Sacnilk reported that the Hindi version received a U certificate with no cuts on October 30. The film opened worldwide on Thursday, November 5.

Reviewers in India, the Gulf, Britain and the United States mostly came away impressed. Sacnilk's roundup of 19 critics, updated November 9, scored the film 75 out of 100. Fourteen reviews were positive, five mixed and none negative. The praise went to the effects, the production design and Yash. The doubts centered on feeling.

The price tag frames those doubts. Producer Namit Malhotra put the combined budget of the two parts at about $500 million, The National reported. The Guardian's headline called it India's most expensive film ever. Critics are weighing whether that money bought a Ramayana that moves audiences as well as dazzles them.

Prime Focus Studios and Monster Mind Creations back the film, and DNEG handled the effects, Esquire India reported. Ranbir Kapoor plays Rama and Sai Pallavi plays Sita. A.R. Rahman and Hans Zimmer share the music.

Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian called the film "a rather amazing adventure." He heard echoes of The Lord of the Rings and Disney's The Lion King in its canvas. The newspaper reviewed it under the international title Ramayana: Rise of a Legend.

William Bibbiani of TheWrap wrote that he had never met the story in school. He described an "electric rainbow of a movie" that ends abruptly because it is half of a whole. Sajin Shrijith of The Week gave it 3.5 out of 5 and said it "looks like a billion dollars." Ankit Ojha of The National gave four stars and advised seeing it in 3D on an IMAX screen.

Yash drew the strongest notices. Rahul Desai of The Hollywood Reporter India wrote that the film lifts whenever Ravana appears. He said the story humanizes the demon king. Great Andhra named Yash the standout in a 3 out of 5 review. The Week singled out the battle between Ravana and Jatayu as the most moving sequence.

Raja Ravi Varma's 1895 oil painting Jatayu Vadham, showing Sita recoiling as Ravana cuts off the wing of the vulture Jatayu "Jatayu Vadham," Raja Ravi Varma's 1895 oil painting of Ravana cutting off Jatayu's wing as Sita watches in horror. Reviewers singled out the same episode in the film, and the painting has no connection with it. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Hindi dub became a talking point. The actor Sharad Kelkar voiced Ravana in that version. He told Outlook that Yash's rhythm with Hindi words was a bit of an issue, though he added that Yash speaks Hindi well. In another interview, he described the character as "a hero on the wrong side".

Ranbir Kapoor's Ram split the room. Great Andhra found him dignified and restrained, with the piety the part needs. Aishani Biswas of Outlook gave the film 2.5 out of 5 and wrote that his Ram seems anxious and short of the composure the role calls for. She found Sita, Kaikeyi and Bharat underdeveloped. In her view the spiritual core gets lost behind the effects.

Somya Mehta of Khaleej Times called the film a milestone for Indian cinema. She also wrote that it may not always capture the spiritual depth of the epic. Kapoor, she said, plays a righteous man better than a figure with divine presence. Desai described the film's approach as "media-trained mythology."

Sai Pallavi's Sita drew gentler notices. Gulte praised her expressive eyes, and The Week praised her as a warrior princess in the fight scenes. Outlook called her sincere and wanted more room for her bond with Ram. Bradshaw noted that the film has no musical numbers.

Critics split on the music as well. Mehta ranked the Zimmer and Rahman score among the film's greatest strengths. Shrijith heard echoes of Zimmer's earlier work and weaker versions of Rahman's. Great Andhra found Rahman's songs forgettable and Zimmer's background score effective. The Gulte reviewer timed the film at 3 hours 15 minutes and found the score soulful. The pace, the reviewer felt, sags in places.

Earlier screen Ramayanas shadow the reviews. Ojha noted that Arun Govil, who played Rama in Ramanand Sagar's Doordarshan series, now plays Dasharatha. Doordarshan said its 2020 lockdown rerun of that series drew 7.7 crore viewers in a single day. The broadcaster announced that figure itself.

Swathi P. Ajith of Onmanorama wrote that the new film looks far better than Adipurush. She found the computer-generated creatures less convincing in the second half. The main characters, she added, look unrealistically clean after battles.

At the box office, trackers disagree. Sacnilk's Day 16 report on November 20 put the worldwide gross at ₹1,574.60 crore. India accounted for ₹1,051.60 crore and overseas for ₹523 crore. Sacnilk called the overseas numbers rough estimates.

Koimoi's Day 15 count put India net at ₹900.93 crore. Sacnilk had ₹880.05 crore a day later.

The opening day was smaller at home than Adipurush's. Sacnilk estimated ₹64.85 crore net in India, against ₹86.75 crore net for the 2023 film. Hollywood Reporter India put the gap down to a pre-Diwali Thursday release.

Overseas, the numbers ran ahead. Pinkvilla reported a UK opening-day record for a Bollywood film of £440,000, plus a US opening day of $2.8 million. It described all figures as trade estimates.

Koimoi counted $51.75 million overseas after 11 days as of November 17. North America supplied about $24 million, the UK and Ireland $5.55 million and the Gulf $5.40 million. Sacnilk credited the importance of the Indian diaspora for North America's lead. It called the Middle East comparatively weaker.

Audience reaction followed the critics. WION's roundup of posts on X found viewers praising Yash, the visuals and the Jatayu sequence. One post called the pacing slow. Khaleej Times collected reactions that included the filmmaker Karan Johar saying he was "blown away."

Gulf News, citing Sacnilk, reported Hindi-version occupancy of 54.6 percent on the sixth day. Bengaluru's 3D shows ran at 90.5 percent. Hyderabad stood at 37.3 percent.

Part 2 will not arrive at Diwali 2027 as first announced. Malhotra confirmed to E! News that it has moved to Diwali 2028. Gulf News reported that the new date first appeared in the end credits of Part 1. The makers called it a production decision.

"We didn't want to do a rush job or get ahead of ourselves," Malhotra said. The delay also clears the field for Sandeep Reddy Vanga's Spirit, set for Diwali 2027. Prabhas stars in it.

RamayanaRamayana Part OneRanbir KapoorYashSai PallaviNitesh TiwariNamit MalhotraHans ZimmerA.R. Rahmanfilm reviewsbox officeDiwaliRamanand SagarAdipurush

Share this story

Comments

Loading comments…

The Thoughtful India newsletter

The week’s best, in your inbox.

Related Stories

Bolly Volley Volume 5
Bollywood

Bolly Volley Volume 5

Ah, Diwali is less than a week away! It always brings back memories of the days when it was okay to burst a loud “chocolate bomb” just about anywhere. Words…

· 5 min read

More Stories